Can Taylor Swift Actually Sue Kanye West for Using Her Naked Body in "Famous"?

No mention of a lawsuit yet, but this legal breakdown puts things in perspective.

Entertainment
26,672 Hypes 0 Comments

It’s been recently reported that Taylor Swift wasn’t too thrilled about Kanye West’s new “Famous” video, where she is depicted as a topless wax figure lying next to the 38-year-old rapper on a gigantic bed alongside other popular celebrities. According to Hollywood Life, a source close to the Swift camp said “Taylor is livid. Taylor is horrified [by the ‘Famous’ music video]. Taylor didn’t know what to do when she heard about what Kanye did. She is bewildered, feels betrayed and is beyond frustrated with Kanye. It is like a complete nightmare. Taylor is pissed to say the least!”

While no mention of a lawsuit is in the works against Kanye, could the celebrities who were depicted in the video actually have a basis for a case? In this breakdown by Forbes legal entertainment contributor, Nicholas Rozansky, he points out three options those involved could have for an actionable cause — these include copyright infringement, defamation and right to publicity. He points out that the “right of publicity” is their best bet for action.

In terms of a copyright infringement suit he states:

The use of a celebrity’s image in itself would not make Mr. West liable for copyright infringement. Rather, the lawsuit would be over Kanye’s depiction of these figures as a “derivative work.” In other words, if Kanye, or the wax sculptor under his direction, used an existing photograph, video, or other image to create the derivative work – the sleeping wax figures, the owner of that copyright may have a colorable lawsuit against Mr. West. Given that these wax figurines seem to be custom made, and the damages for copyright infringement are limited here, this cause of action seems unlikely.

In terms of a defamation suit:

Because of the sexual nature of the depiction, the celebrities may sue Mr. West for defamation under a slander per se theory. This is because slander is defined in the California Civil Code as a “false and unprivileged publication…by radio or any mechanical or other means which” among other things “imputes someone to a want of chastity…or [w]hich, by natural consequence, causes actual damage” (Cal. Civ. Code, § 46.).

The celebrities here will have to simply show that the image Mr. West created is associated with them, and is depicting them in an unchaste act. Given the image itself, it may seem obvious that such a cause of action would be appropriate. And, slander per se is actionable without proof of special damage (Gonzalez v. Fire Insurance Exchange (App. 6 Dist. 2015) 184 Cal.Rptr.3d 394, 234 Cal.App.4th 1220). This means that the celebrities who sue do not have to show that their reputations were actually harmed just to get past the initial phases of a lawsuit against Mr. West.

However, Mr. Nicholas Rozansky says that “first amendment” defense may work here as Kanye could just be stating personal opinions about the celebrities in his own way.

In terms of the right to publicity:

The right of publicity, often called personality rights, is the right of an individual to control the commercial use of his or her name, image, likeness, or other unequivocal aspects of one’s identity. California, recognizing the large amount of celebrities who call this state home, codified protections for its most well-known citizens in the Celebrity Rights Act in 1985 (Cal. Civ. Code §3344).

Under Cal. Civil Code §3344 “any person who knowingly uses another’s…likeness, in any manner…for purposes of advertising or selling, or soliciting purchases of, products, merchandise, goods or services, without such person’s prior consent…shall be liable for any damages sustained by the person or persons injured as a result thereof.”

It will be interesting to see what plays out in the coming months. Will some choose to sue or just keep quiet? Either way, Kanye is contributing to their fame, helping all of them stay current in the pop culture conversation. Also, while some of the celebrities shown in the video have kept silent, some have actually made some public reactions. Chris Brown was actually more humorous about the video, stating on Instagram, “Why I gotta have the plumbers butt/crack showing WAX figure?”

Read Full Article

What to Read Next

Kanye West, Taylor Swift and More Received GRAMMY Nominations Due to Last-Minute Rule Change
Music

Kanye West, Taylor Swift and More Received GRAMMY Nominations Due to Last-Minute Rule Change

The Academy CEO explained that it allowed them “to honor more artists and shine a light on more great music.”

Soulja Boy Tells Kanye West To Apologize to Taylor Swift in Twitter Rant
Music

Soulja Boy Tells Kanye West To Apologize to Taylor Swift in Twitter Rant

Also leaking his removed verse on Ye’s ‘DONDA’ cut “Remote Control.”

Drake Recorded Verses for Kanye West’s “Yikes,” Producer Says
Music

Drake Recorded Verses for Kanye West’s “Yikes,” Producer Says

Drake was ultimately credited as one of the track’s writers.


Watch Kanye West's Latest Sunday Service in Los Angeles
Music

Watch Kanye West's Latest Sunday Service in Los Angeles

The Sunday Service Choir performed renditions of Frank Ocean’s “Lost,” holiday songs and more.

The Artist Behind Kanye West's "Famous" Video Explains How It All Transpired
Music 

The Artist Behind Kanye West's "Famous" Video Explains How It All Transpired

“I felt as if I had been presented with the most extraordinary gift.”

More Zombies, Dragons & Multiplayer Maps in the New 'Call of Duty: Black Ops III' Descent DLC Pack
Gaming

More Zombies, Dragons & Multiplayer Maps in the New 'Call of Duty: Black Ops III' Descent DLC Pack

The latest expansion for the ‘Black Ops III: Zombies’ series.

Willow Smith is The New Face of Chanel
Music 

Willow Smith is The New Face of Chanel

Willow Smith’s Chanel campaign has arrived.

Alexander Wang Takes the Reins as Eponymous Label's CEO and Chairman
Fashion

Alexander Wang Takes the Reins as Eponymous Label's CEO and Chairman

Along with a new team of senior level staff.

Gucci Mane is Getting His Own Reality Show
Music 

Gucci Mane is Getting His Own Reality Show

Gucci Mane is coming to television.


Nike's LeBron Soldier 10 Silhouette Receives the "Think Pink" Theme
Footwear

Nike's LeBron Soldier 10 Silhouette Receives the "Think Pink" Theme

The Soldier 10 joins the beneficial lineup for the Kay Yow Cancer Fund.

Kanye West's "Famous" Video is Making Ray J Upset
Music 

Kanye West's "Famous" Video is Making Ray J Upset

“It’s all bad in my world, and that ain’t cool.”

5 Sneaker Resellers Share Tips on the Game
Footwear 

5 Sneaker Resellers Share Tips on the Game

“I’m not a reseller. I’m a reformed addict.”

13thWitness and Futura Shoot the Streets of Toronto With #TheCreatorClass
Art

13thWitness and Futura Shoot the Streets of Toronto With #TheCreatorClass

The father-son duo also spoke about their creative processes and the influence of the street on their work.

Études Studio's 2017 Spring/Summer Collection Redefines Street Chic
Fashion

Études Studio's 2017 Spring/Summer Collection Redefines Street Chic

From sophisticated cuts to apocalyptic-esque outerwear designs.

More ▾
 
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Gain access to exclusive interviews with industry creatives, think pieces, trend forecasts, guides and more.

By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Looks like you’re using an ad-blocker

We charge advertisers instead of our readers. If you enjoy our content, please whitelist our site to show your support. We’d really appreciate it.

Whitelist Us

How to Whitelist Us

screenshot
  1. Click the AdBlock icon in the browser extension area in the upper right-hand corner.
  2. Under “Pause on this site” click “Always”.
  3. Refresh the page or click the button below to continue.
screenshot
  1. Click the AdBlock Plus icon in the browser extension area in the upper right-hand corner.
  2. Block ads on – This website” switch off the toggle to turn it from blue to gray.
  3. Refresh the page or click the button below to continue.
screenshot
  1. Click the AdBlocker Ultimate icon in the browser extension area in the upper right-hand corner.
  2. Switch off the toggle to turn it from “Enabled on this site” to “Disabled on this site”.
  3. Refresh the page or click the button below to continue.
screenshot
  1. Click the Ghostery icon in the browser extension area in the upper right-hand corner.
  2. Click on the “Ad-Blocking” button at the bottom. It will turn gray and the text above will go from “ON” to “OFF”.
  3. Refresh the page or click the button below to continue.
screenshot
  1. Click the UBlock Origin icon in the browser extension area in the upper right-hand corner.
  2. Click on the large blue power icon at the top.
  3. When it turns gray, click the refresh icon that has appeared next to it or click the button below to continue.
screenshot
  1. Click the icon of the ad-blocker extension installed on your browser.You’ll usually find this icon in the upper right-hand corner of your screen. You may have more than one ad-blocker installed.
  2. Follow the instructions for disabling the ad blocker on the site you’re viewing.You may have to select a menu option or click a button.
  3. Refresh the page or click the button below to continue.