Legal dispute between Megaupload and Universal Music Group takes interesting turn

As previously reported, Megaupload uploaded a promo video on YouTube a week ago featuring a

Music 
70 Hypes 0 Comments

As previously reported, Megaupload uploaded a promo video on YouTube a week ago featuring a raft of high profile artists and was quickly removed after Universal Music Group (UMG) complained. After Megaupload sued UMG on Monday in return and asked the court to bar UMG from blocking the distribution or display of the video, the clip was back online. Its reappearance results from UMG’s failing to assert valid ownership rights. In a somewhat interesting turn, the company now states that never claimed copyright ownership, despite using YouTube’s automated tools for copyright owners to request takedowns. However, UMG says that it does have other rights which imply that the company is authorized to request the video removal because of a certain written agreement with YouTube. Details on what the agreement covers and why it applies have not been revealed. UMG’s lawyers turned in a filing on Friday night urging the court to reject Megaupload’s request for a temporary restraining order and submitted a copy of a letter UMG attorney Kelly Klaus sent to YouTube on Wednesday that refers to a specific agreement.

“What actually transpired was UMG’s use of YouTube’s Content Management System, which UMG is contractually authorized to use pursuant to its written agreement with YouTube. That is a matter of contract between two private companies–UMG and YouTube–not a notice sent pursuant to the DMCA.

Your letter could be read to suggest that UMG’s rights to use the YouTube ‘Content Management System’ with respect to certain user-posted videos are limited to instances in which UMG asserts a claim that a user-posted video contains material that infringes a UMG copyright,” Klaus wrote. “As you know, UMG’s rights in this regard are not limited to copyright infringement, as set forth more completely in the March 31, 2009 Video License Agreement for UGC Video Service Providers, including without limitation Paragraphs 1(b) and 1(g) thereof.”

A YouTube representative declined to comment on the matter beyond providing following statement:

“Our partners do not have the right to take down videos from YouTube unless they own the rights to them or they are live performances controlled through exclusive agreements with their artists, which is why we reinstated it.”

Thus, it is likely that the mystery agreement covers artists under contract with UMG who have a live performance that appears in a video on YouTube. Regardless, YouTube apparently doesn’t think UMG’s takedown request was valid. Obviously, Megaupload attorney Ira Rothken has a certain opinion on UMG’s latest move:

“UMG is now claiming that it has a private, automated censorship right–supported by a secret process that can take down any YouTube video with immunity from the DMCA–and there is nothing that this Court could do about it. UMG’s actions and their continuing harm implicate important speech suppression issues, warranting immediate and narrow discovery to test the integrity of UMG’s argument, and the extent of its continued interference with the full and fair display of the video, in preparation for the preliminary injunction hearing.”

Share your thoughts on this delicate matter below.

Source: CNET

Read Full Article

What to Read Next

Universal Music Group Creates Bored Ape Yacht Club Band Called KINGSHIP
Tech

Universal Music Group Creates Bored Ape Yacht Club Band Called KINGSHIP

Made up of a Mutant Ape and three Bored Ape characters, including rare Golden Fur and Bluebeam Apes.

Four Tet Takes Legal Action Against Domino Over Royalties Dispute Related to Streaming
Music

Four Tet Takes Legal Action Against Domino Over Royalties Dispute Related to Streaming

The IDM artist signed with the label in 2001 — seven years before Spotify launched.

Universal Works and The Pilgrm Reunite for Second Sustainable Capsule
Fashion

Universal Works and The Pilgrm Reunite for Second Sustainable Capsule

Creating relaxed fits and laid-back staples.


IDK Announces "No Label Academy" Music Program With Harvard University for BIPOC Students
Music

IDK Announces "No Label Academy" Music Program With Harvard University for BIPOC Students

The free 10-day course will take place this August at the Harvard University campus.

VOYR: Kanye West and Jay-Z “Watch the Throne” Tour Behind-the-Scenes Episode 6
Music 

VOYR: Kanye West and Jay-Z “Watch the Throne” Tour Behind-the-Scenes Episode 6

Here comes the sixth installment of the behind-the-scenes impressions series highlighting Kanye

50 Cent - Off and On
Music 

50 Cent - Off and On

Fresh from letting loose his recent mixtape The Big 10, Curtis is already cranking out the

Piet Side Tables by Hugo Passos
Fashion

Piet Side Tables by Hugo Passos

Portuguese-born and London-based designer Hugo Passos has brought together design sensibilities

The Superior Labor Market Bag
Fashion

The Superior Labor Market Bag

Superior Labor has saved the best for last, delivering their range of Market Bags in an array of

Samurai Denim Down Vest
Fashion

Samurai Denim Down Vest

Samurai has showcased its latest piece, a Down Vest, which boasts 17oz. luxurious denim and paired


Cartier Skeleton Pocket Watch
Watches

Cartier Skeleton Pocket Watch

The Cartier Skeleton Pocket Watch is every bit a piece of functioning art work as it is a

BBC: Steve Jobs - Billion Dollar Hippy
Tech

BBC: Steve Jobs - Billion Dollar Hippy

After his death from cancer in October, the BBC Two started crafting a nearly one-hour documentary

White Walls: Art Basel Miami 2011 Video
Art

White Walls: Art Basel Miami 2011 Video

White Walls hosted four booths at SCOPE, situated in the center of Miami’s Wynwood Gallery Arts

Blank Snowboards: Salt Boarding
Sports

Blank Snowboards: Salt Boarding

With filmmaker Devin Graham at the helm, the crew at Blank Snowboards ventured to the Bonneville

Wiz Khalifa - California
Music

Wiz Khalifa - California

From the upcoming mixtape Taylor Allderdice, Wiz Khalifa rolls out the visuals for “California.” It

More ▾
 
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Gain access to exclusive interviews with industry creatives, think pieces, trend forecasts, guides and more.

By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Adblock Detected.

We charge advertisers instead of our readers. If you enjoy our content, please add us to your adblocker's whitelist. We'd really appreciated it.