AI Prize Recipient Disqualified After Submitting a Real Photograph

“I entered this actual photo into the AI category of 1839 Awards to prove that human-made content has not lost its relevance.”

Art
2.8K 1 Comments

For better and worse, the creative industry is one of the biggest industries that has been impacted by the rise of artificial intelligence (AI). On one end, users are able to moodboard, and many instances, bypass numerous hurdles to realizing a creative thought or brief in a matter of seconds — without the need of rigorous sketches, camera crews or creative collaborations. On the opposite spectrum, it’s been reported numerous times that these machine learning systems are illegally using the intellectual property of millions of artists without consent or repercussion, setting the stage for what many creative professionals fear to be an uncertain landscape going forward.

In April of 2023, an AI-produced image created a storm of controversy when it won Sony’s World Photography Awards. To the company’s defense, it was not aware of the means in which the image was produced — but the fact that it wasn’t able to be detected, signaled the real threat to the future of photography industry. To flip the scenario, photographer Miles Astray recently won the third-place prize for an AI photo competition, but was disqualified when he revealed that his submission was indeed a real photograph.

Astray’s image depicts a flamingo with it’s head is tucked away from the camera, as it stands against a sandy beach with the ocean just creeping in the distance. Entitled F L A M I N G O N E, the artwork is meant to signal the importance of pictures made by humans. He explained further:

“With AI-generated content remodelling the digital landscape rapidly while sparking an ever-fiercer debate about its implications for the future of content and the creators behind it – from creatives like artists, journalists, and graphic designers to employees in all sorts of industries – I entered this actual photo into the AI category of 1839 Awards to prove that human-made content has not lost its relevance, that Mother Nature and her human interpreters can still beat the machine, and that creativity and emotion are more than just a string of digits.”

It should come as no surprise that Astray’s image was disqualified, but the real prize, according to the photographer, was a win “for many creatives out there,” he added. “I won’t go as far as to say that it’s a win for Mother Nature herself because I think she’s got bigger things on her plate; who knows, maybe AI can help her with that, by computing climate change models and the likes.”

Read Full Article

What to Read Next

Novel AI Technology Literally Sniffs Out Counterfeit Sneakers
Tech & Gadgets

Novel AI Technology Literally Sniffs Out Counterfeit Sneakers

Osmo AI uses sensors that analyze scent signatures to authenticate shoes and luxury goods.

Toyota Drifts Two GR Supras Autonomously Using AI
Automotive

Toyota Drifts Two GR Supras Autonomously Using AI

Made possible in partnership with Stanford Engineering and marking the world’s first fully autonomous tandem drift sequence.

Nintendo Boss Shuntaro Furukawa Comments on Company's Stance on Using Generative AI
Gaming

Nintendo Boss Shuntaro Furukawa Comments on Company's Stance on Using Generative AI

Specifically clarifying Nintendo’s future plans on using generative AI to create new games.


Dana-Fiona Armour Awarded Inaugural Sigg Art Prize
Art

Dana-Fiona Armour Awarded Inaugural Sigg Art Prize

Amidst the selection jury you can find curators, writers, collectors and an AI judge.

Soho House Announces Its First Japan Location
Travel

Soho House Announces Its First Japan Location

Set to open in 2026, Soho House’s inaugural Japan location will be located in Tokyo’s Aoyama neighborhood.

Visualizing the Vanguard: How Rhymezlikedimez Became Hip-Hop's Favorite Animator
Art 

Visualizing the Vanguard: How Rhymezlikedimez Became Hip-Hop's Favorite Animator

Fresh off his contributions to NxWorries’ ‘Why Lawd?’ LP and a comic series in the pipeline, Rhymezlikedimez details his colorful career trajectory: catching Stones Throw’s eye early in the game, coining the term “visualizer” and racking up A-list credits.

Nike Air Max 2013 Receives a Futuristic "Metallic Silver" Treatment
Footwear

Nike Air Max 2013 Receives a Futuristic "Metallic Silver" Treatment

Available now.

An Air Jordan 1 Hi ‘85 “Reverse Shadow” Is Coming in 2025
Footwear

An Air Jordan 1 Hi ‘85 “Reverse Shadow” Is Coming in 2025

The Air Jordan 1’s 40th anniversary is shaping up to be a big one.

KidSuper's Spring 2025 Show Is Going to Be a Cirque du Soleil Spectacle
Fashion

KidSuper's Spring 2025 Show Is Going to Be a Cirque du Soleil Spectacle

Colm Dillane’s fashion brand has partnered with the world-renowned entertainment group for its upcoming Paris Fashion Week show.


Forét SS25 Is Down to Earth
Fashion

Forét SS25 Is Down to Earth

The Scandinavian label goes outside to create its latest collection, “Bees and Things and Flowers.”

Marvel's 'Blade' Film Sees Its Second Director Exit the Project
Entertainment

Marvel's 'Blade' Film Sees Its Second Director Exit the Project

A familiar storyline that sees Yann Demange bite the dust following Bassam Tariq in 2022.

Veronica Fernandez & Tidawhitney Lek Ask 'What Will You Give?'
Art

Veronica Fernandez & Tidawhitney Lek Ask 'What Will You Give?'

Unveiling narratives of love and loss at Sidecar Gallery.

Superposition Gallery Exhibition Questions New Realities
Art

Superposition Gallery Exhibition Questions New Realities

Delving into Saturn’s return, a cosmic event that prompts introspection.

Chris Stamp Shares His Travel Guide to Aspen, Colorado
City Guides

Chris Stamp Shares His Travel Guide to Aspen, Colorado

The STAMPD founder shows us where he eats, sleeps and shops when visiting the luxury mountain town.

More ▾