Drake Beats “Pound Cake/Paris Morton Music 2” Sample Lawsuit

Judge Pauley says Drake’s use is “transformative” and “adds something new.”

Music
4,372 Hypes 0 Comments

Drake was hit with a lawsuit in 2014 over the vocal sample that opens his JAY Z-featured Nothing Was the Same record “Pound Cake/Paris Morton Music 2.” The copyright infringement lawsuit was filed by jazz artist Jimmy Smith. Smith’s 1982 track “Jimmy Smith Rap,” as well as “Don’t Say A Word” by Ellie Goulding, “Jimmy Smith Rap” by Jimmy Smith, and “C.R.E.A.M.” by Wu-Tang Clan were sampled on the song, which was produced by Boi-1da and Jordan Evans. Yesterday, a judge ruled that the sample is fair use, THR reported, and that there is no liability for copyright infringement. As noted by Pitchfork, U.S. District Court judge William H. Pauley III explains:

In the original, Smith says, “Jazz is the only real music that’s gonna last. All that other bullshit is here today and gone tomorrow. But jazz was, is and always will be.” In Drake’s version, it’s cut down to, “Only real music’s gonna last. All that other bullshit is here today and gone tomorrow.” Judge Pauley notes that Smith’s original “is an unequivocal statement on the primacy of jazz over all other forms of popular music” while Drake’s version turns it into “a statement that ‘real music,’ with no qualifiers, is ‘the only thing that’s gonna last.’”

Because the purpose of the “Pound Cake” edit is “sharply different” from Smith’s original message, Judge Pauley argues Drake’s use “adds something new” and is “transformative.” Therefore, he writes, “this factor weighs in favor of a finding of fair use.”

Check out a more extensive report on the case here. Listen to “Pound Cake/Paris Morton Music 2” and compare it to the original “Jimmy Smith Rap” below.

Read Full Article

What to Read Next

Here Is Every Sample on Drake’s 'Certified Lover Boy’ Album
Music

Here Is Every Sample on Drake’s 'Certified Lover Boy’ Album

The Canadian artist drew from Notorious B.I.G., *NSYNC, Bun B, Three 6 Mafia and more.

Travis Scott, Drake, Live Nation and More Face $2 Billion USD Lawsuit Following Astroworld Tragedy
Music

Travis Scott, Drake, Live Nation and More Face $2 Billion USD Lawsuit Following Astroworld Tragedy

The class-action lawsuit was filed on behalf of 282 attendees.

$750 Million USD Lawsuit Filed Against Travis Scott, Drake, Live Nation and Apple Music Over Astroworld Tragedy
Music

$750 Million USD Lawsuit Filed Against Travis Scott, Drake, Live Nation and Apple Music Over Astroworld Tragedy

Attorney Tony Buzbee filed the lawsuit on behalf of 125 attendees including the family of Axel Acosta, one of the victims.


Drake Releases Comical "Way 2 Sexy" Music Video Featuring Future and Young Thug
Music

Drake Releases Comical "Way 2 Sexy" Music Video Featuring Future and Young Thug

The cheeky visual features a Kawhi Leonard cameo, nods to Michael Jackson, Backstreet Boys and more.

HYPEBEAST RADIO Is Now Live: In-Depth Conversations With Artists, Designers and More
Music

HYPEBEAST RADIO Is Now Live: In-Depth Conversations With Artists, Designers and More

Learn what’s really going on with your favorite artists, designers, models, and industry leaders.

Illegal Civilization Debuts New 'IC3' Trailer and Skate Program Lookbook
Entertainment

Illegal Civilization Debuts New 'IC3' Trailer and Skate Program Lookbook

The skate crew’s third full-length skate video is coming to VICELAND soon.

adidas Unveils the UltraBOOST 3.0 In "Noble Ink"
Footwear

adidas Unveils the UltraBOOST 3.0 In "Noble Ink"

Expected to join this summer’s rotation.

Here's Why Bryson Tiller Dropped 'True to Self' a Month Early
Music

Here's Why Bryson Tiller Dropped 'True to Self' a Month Early

He also forgot about it.

An 'Animaniacs' Reboot Is in the Works From Steven Spielberg
Entertainment

An 'Animaniacs' Reboot Is in the Works From Steven Spielberg

The pop culture heavy fan favorite show makes a return.


LaVar Ball Turned Down a $10 Million USD Shoe Deal for Lonzo
Sports

LaVar Ball Turned Down a $10 Million USD Shoe Deal for Lonzo

Searching for a “more lucrative” offer.

Watch the Nintendo Switch Go Through a 1,000 Feet Drop Test
Gaming

Watch the Nintendo Switch Go Through a 1,000 Feet Drop Test

Will the gaming console survive?

Rich Homie Quan Could Face up to 30 Years in Prison
Music

Rich Homie Quan Could Face up to 30 Years in Prison

For felony drug charges.

The Air Max 1 "Master" Gets Fitted With White Python by The Shoe Surgeon
Footwear

The Air Max 1 "Master" Gets Fitted With White Python by The Shoe Surgeon

The bold colorway gets bolder.

An MF Doom & Jay Electronica Collaboration Is Coming via Adult Swim
Music

An MF Doom & Jay Electronica Collaboration Is Coming via Adult Swim

It’s a “brand new jam.”

More ▾
 
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Gain access to exclusive interviews with industry creatives, think pieces, trend forecasts, guides and more.

By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Adblock Detected

We charge advertisers instead of our readers. If you enjoy our content, please add us to your adblocker's whitelist. We'd really appreciated it.