Jeremy Scott Sued for Stealing Graffiti Art Designs, Says Graffiti Should Not Be Recognized by the Law

Is graffiti legally protected by copyright infringement?

By //Fashion

Both Moschino and the label’s creative director and designer Jeremy Scott are named in a hefty lawsuit by Brooklyn-based artist Joseph Tierney, also known as RIME. As The Fashion Law reports, Scott is accused of lifting an exact copy of Tierney’s graffiti art known as “Vandal Eyes” for Moschino’s previous collection (most notably on pieces worn by Gigi Hadid on the runway and Katy Perry at the Metropolitan Museum of Art Costume Institute Gala). “Moschino and Scott released a capsule collection featuring graphic designs that included literal copies of images of [RIME's] mural. To add insult to injury, Moschino and Scott also included a forgery of Plaintiff’s signature and Plaintiff’s name ‘Rime’ throughout the collection,” states Tierney’s motion.

While the design is uncannily similar, Scott refutes the case stating graffiti is an act of vandalism and should not be protected by law. Moschino and Scott’s motion reports, “As a matter of public policy and basic logic, it would make no sense to grant legal protection to work that is created entirely illegally. Brazen and willful violations of the law cannot, and, indeed, should not result in the award of copyright privileges.” In regards to the designs copying RIMES’ signature tag, the label and designer argue back it was added “to create an urban feel” for the design’s graffiti theme.

Moschino and Scott’s legal team went a step further by referencing the famous unsolved case of the Black Dahlia murder in 1947, stipulating that the killer could not sue police and the media for disassembling and distributing his “criminal handiwork” aka the mutilated body of 22-year-old Elizabeth Short. While reports state Moschino and Scott’s legal counsel have been accused of straying off topic throughout the case, RIMES goes on to accuse the legal team of bullying, acting unethically and intentionally misconstruing the law. “To meet their goal of asserting multiple challenges to each and every cause of action,” the motion reports, “Defendants must dig deep for grounds that rely on a far too stringent fact pleading standard, or on misstatements of law.”

Tierney indeed did not have permission from the owner of the building in Detroit which he tagged his mural on, but do you think this is a case of copyright infringement or not? Watch the making of the original art piece and leave your thoughts below.

Read Full Article
Photographer
Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images
Jeremy ScottRimemoschinoLawsuitsRimes

You may also like

Virgil Abloh Designs Cover Art for Global Dan's "Off-White" Remix
Music

Virgil Abloh Designs Cover Art for Global Dan's "Off-White" Remix

Featuring guest spots from Rich The Kid & MadeinTYO.
6,080 Hypes 0 Comments
7 Marvel Comic Arcs That Should Be Adapted for the MCU
Entertainment

7 Marvel Comic Arcs That Should Be Adapted for the MCU

Nearly 80 years worth of stories to pick from.
9,398 Hypes 9 Comments
Offset & Cardi B Faces Another Lawsuit Over Alleged Hotel Assault
Music

Offset & Cardi B Faces Another Lawsuit Over Alleged Hotel Assault

Offset was also reportedly arrested for gun possession.
115 Hypes 0 Comments
Instagram Adds New Activity Status Indicator
Tech

Instagram Adds New Activity Status Indicator

Friends will now be able to see when you’re active on the app.
111 Hypes 0 Comments
Linkin Park Pays Tribute to Chester Bennington on 1-Year Anniversary of His Death
Music

Linkin Park Pays Tribute to Chester Bennington on 1-Year Anniversary of His Death

“Your one-of-a-kind spirit has authored an indelible imprint on our hearts.”
1,686 Hypes 1 Comments


What to Read Next

Charli XCX's New "Vroom Vroom" Video Might Be Her Best Yet
Music 

Charli XCX's New "Vroom Vroom" Video Might Be Her Best Yet

One of the sexiest and coolest videos released in 2016 thus far.

T.I.'s Bankroll Mafia Drop Self-Titled Debut Project
Music 

T.I.'s Bankroll Mafia Drop Self-Titled Debut Project

Migos, Lil Yachty and more contribute.

Find Which 'Game of Thrones' Character You Are With Spotify
Fashion

Find Which 'Game of Thrones' Character You Are With Spotify

With whom do you listen?


Gotye Returns with Cover of Prince's "Sometimes It Snows In April"
Music 

Gotye Returns with Cover of Prince's "Sometimes It Snows In April"

A very rare Gotye appearance.

Mila J Reflects on Troubled Past Relationships for "TBH"
Music 

Mila J Reflects on Troubled Past Relationships for "TBH"

She’s been going hard for many months now.

Take a Look Inside Soho House's Farmhouse Retreat
Design

Take a Look Inside Soho House's Farmhouse Retreat

The private member’s club designs a stunning 100 acre farm with an 80+ foot long pool.

More ▾