hasejun1985
02-17-2006, 04:10 AM
by Carlos at the old forum, and now, its here again.
Clean kicks are of the essence and there comes a time in every sneaker-fiend’s life when he has to roll up his sleeves and risk doing more damage to his dirty kicks by cleaning them instead of ignoring them.
The results are in. After scouring the Internet for sneaker cleaning tips, I tested the popular ones on various materials and fabrics using them for their intended purposes. In other words, I didn’t use the Clorox Bleach Pen on materials that were color-dyed and I didn’t use Mr. Clean Magic Eraser on delicate fabrics or patent leather. Some products cleaned as expected, others not so well, and others better than anticipated.
Below you’ll find a summary of the best sneaker cleaning products around. They’re ranked and categorized by the materials they’re intended to clean, followed by a detailed review of each product. Overall ratings were determined by product availability, cost, effectiveness and ingredients contained. You’ll see that not one cleaner earned a 10 out of 10 rating---although a few come very close---because not one cleaned perfectly and not one cleaned the single most-difficult cleaning task in shoe history: the dirty mid-sole of a Jordan III (Retro or O.G.)
The MORELWORKS Sneaker Cleaning Philosophy
*The best maintenance is preventive
*Wear your sneakers with care
*Protect them with sneaker protector/water repellent
*Clean your kicks regularly, but with the least amount of cleaners, abrasives or solutions
*Test cleaning agents on a small area (e.g. the shoe-arch) before smothering the entire shoe
Bare Essentials Shoe Cleaning Kit $12
1. Paper Towel and/or Rag (wiper/scrubber)$1
2. Toothbrush (scrubber) $2
3. Dishwashing liquid (basic shoe sole & mid-sole cleaner) $1
4. Woolite (basic shoe-upper cleaner) $5
5. Shout (stain remover) $3
Upscale Shoe Cleaning Kit $33
1. The Essentials Cleaning Kit (basic supplies) $11
2. Mr. Clean Magic Eraser (tough-stain removal) $2
3. ShoeMGK Cleaner & Conditioner (all-around cleaning) $10
4. Windex (patent leather) $4
*OPTIONAL: Add $10 for a Nubuck/Suede Cleaning Kit if you have shoes made of nubuck/suede or synthetic nubuck/suede
RESULTS AT-A-GLANCE
SHOE-UPPERS: Canvas, Mesh, Vinyl
General Cleaning
1st Choice: Woolite $4
2nd Choice: ShoeMGK Cleaner and Conditioner $10
Last Choice: Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action Gel Cleaner $5
Woolite is my first choice because it’s gentle, effective, easy to acquire and the cheapest of the lot. It also has an established reputation of cleaning delicate fabrics since Mom’s around the world trust their delicates to the stuff. ShoeMGK, although an excellent cleaner, comes in second because of its high price, difficulty to obtain and newness to the cleaning market. The Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action Gel Cleaner rounds out the pack as a more expensive version of laundry detergent.
Stain Removal: WHITES
1st Choice: Clorox Bleach Pen $4
2nd Choice: Shout/Spray N Wash/OxiClean $3
Last Choice: Woolite $4
Clorox Bleach Pen runs circles around every other cleaner when it comes to getting whites white. Generic stain removals are the next best thing and, for day-to-day use, Woolite and some water should do the trick.
Stain Removal: COLORS
1st Choice: Shout/Spray N Wash/OxiClean $3
2nd Choice: Woolite $4
Last Choice: ShoeMGK Cleaner and Conditioner $10
*Wildcard: Mr. Clean Magic Eraser
For colors, products designed for stain removal come in first place, while Woolite (fortified with some elbow grease) comes in second. ShoeMGK Cleaner, although an effective all-around cleaner, comes in the last, again, because of its price and difficulty to obtain. The wildcard here is the miracle worker Mr. Clean Magic Eraser: It’s such an effective cleaner, however, it may just ruin your uppers. Although some regularly clean their entire shoes with the Magic, I save it as a last resort, because there are usually equally effective, less harmful alternatives.
SHOE-UPPERS: Patent Leather
Light Soil: Warm water $0
Heavier Soil: Dishwashing liquid and warm water $2
Heaviest Soil: Windex $4
Real patent leather is leather treated with linseed oil and lacquer, polished to a high gloss finish---a process that was once patented, hence the name. The “patent leather” used in most athletic shoes, however, is leather-coated with plastic or entirely made of plastic. It follows, then, that the care of patent leather sneakers is actually the care of flexible plastic. With time plastic patent leather tends to fade, yellow and crack, and any cleaning agents applied to its surface actually help accelerate the aging process, so if cleaning agents are used, they should be the least corrosive available, used infrequently and preferably when other remedies fail.
SHOE-UPPERS: Nubuck/Suede
1st Choice: Nubuck/Suede Cleaning Kit [suede stone, brush & cleaner] $11
Last Choice: Woolite $4
The Cardinal Rule when cleaning nubuck/suede (a specialized form of leather derived from calfskin) has always been: Never use water to clean nubuck/suede. The reason was that water dries out and stains the leather. Traditionally, nubuck/suede care consisted of a using a brush to restore the nap (i.e. fuzz), a suede stone to remove small stains and, as a last resort, spraying aerosol nubuck/suede cleaner and “dry cleaning” the suede.
Many athletic “nubuck” or “suede” shoes, however, are actually made of a synthetic material called “Chlorenol” (a.k.a. “Durabuck” in Nike’s and “Hydrolite” in Avia’s) that has the look and feel of suede, but is less delicate and more durable than the real deal. Nike recommends cleaning Durabuck with “a soft brush and mild soap and water”. I cleaned different sections of my girl’s light blue adidas Campus IIs (real suede) and my Nike Tokyo URL’s (Chlorenol) with Nubuck/Suede cleaner, Woolite, ShoeMGK Cleaner, Shout, Spray N’ Wash and OxiClean…and water. And while none of the detergent cleaners + water ruined our kicks, their use resulted in a clean, but stiff fabric. Use of the aerosol Nubuck/Suede Cleaner, by contrast, resulted in brighter colors and a softer feel in both the real and synthetic suede kicks, so I ended up cleaning them again with the cleaner just to get them to feel soft and velvety again. The moral of the story, then, is that it pays to use a product designed for its specific purpose even if the material is a man-made version of the real thing.
SHOE-BOTTOMS: Soles/Mid-Soles
Light Soil: Dishwashing liquid and warm water
Heavy Soil: Shout/Spray N Wash/Oxi Clean $3 Simple Green $4/Shoe MGK Cleaner & Condtioner $10
Heaviest Soil: COLORED Sole---Mr. Clean Magic Eraser $2
WHITE Sole---Clorox Bleach Pen $4
If you’re careful about how you treat your kicks when you’re wearing them, you shouldn’t need much more than a toothbrush, a drop of dishwashing liquid and a bit of warm water to clean your soles and mid-soles. Sometimes, you gotta kick it up a notch, in which case most all-purpose cleaners will do the trick, but in a pinch you can depend on Mr. Clean Magic Eraser and Clorox Bleach Pen to do the heavy lifting. Again, adhere to the MORELWORKS Shoe Cleaning philosophy: the least amount of chemicals causes the least amount of damage, so start with the least abrasive solutions and work your way up to the more heavy-duty solutions.
PRODUCT REVIEWS
*Clorox Bleach Pen
*Dishwashing Liquid (Joy, Dawn, Palmolive, etc.)
*Eraser (the pencil kind)
*Gel Cleaner (Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action)
*Household Cleaners All-Purpose (e.g. 409, OxiClean, Simple Green)
*Instant Sneaker Cleaner (Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action)
*Isopropyl Alcohol
*Mr. Clean Magic Eraser
*Nubuck/Suede Cleaning Kit
*Shoe MGK Cleaner & Conditioner
*Stain Removers: Shout (OxiClean, Spray N Wash, Shout)
*Window Cleaners: Windex, Rite-Aid Glass Cleaner
*Woolite
Clorox Bleach Pen
USE: White soles, white mid-soles, and white uppers made of vinyl and mesh
OVERALL RATING: 9 out of 10
PRICE: $4
AMOUNT: 2 oz.
This gel bleach-in-a-pen works wonders on whites of all types (e.g. uppers, lowers, rubber, canvas, mesh, etc.) and even beats out Mr. Clean’s Magic Eraser when it comes to cleaning the Vans sidewalls. The pen comes with a double-sided applicator: fine point on one side, broad on the other. The gel is great but the applicator isn’t so ignore the scrubber supplied; it doesn’t work well and you’ll find yourself dispensing a bunch of gel instead of scrubbing your shoes. Instead, apply the gel to a separate brush (e.g. a toothbrush) and get your cleaning on. Any bleach product consistently used will, over time, yellow the item cleaned, so I’d save the Clorox Bleach Pen for heavy soiled items and stick to mild alternatives for day-to-day cleaning. That said, the Clorox Bleach Pen is a must-have in any serious sneaker cleaner’s arsenal.
PROS: Highly effective, dispenses easily, readily available
CONS: Brush/applicator tip is ineffective, cost (for amount supplied), may yellow after repeated use
Clean kicks are of the essence and there comes a time in every sneaker-fiend’s life when he has to roll up his sleeves and risk doing more damage to his dirty kicks by cleaning them instead of ignoring them.
The results are in. After scouring the Internet for sneaker cleaning tips, I tested the popular ones on various materials and fabrics using them for their intended purposes. In other words, I didn’t use the Clorox Bleach Pen on materials that were color-dyed and I didn’t use Mr. Clean Magic Eraser on delicate fabrics or patent leather. Some products cleaned as expected, others not so well, and others better than anticipated.
Below you’ll find a summary of the best sneaker cleaning products around. They’re ranked and categorized by the materials they’re intended to clean, followed by a detailed review of each product. Overall ratings were determined by product availability, cost, effectiveness and ingredients contained. You’ll see that not one cleaner earned a 10 out of 10 rating---although a few come very close---because not one cleaned perfectly and not one cleaned the single most-difficult cleaning task in shoe history: the dirty mid-sole of a Jordan III (Retro or O.G.)
The MORELWORKS Sneaker Cleaning Philosophy
*The best maintenance is preventive
*Wear your sneakers with care
*Protect them with sneaker protector/water repellent
*Clean your kicks regularly, but with the least amount of cleaners, abrasives or solutions
*Test cleaning agents on a small area (e.g. the shoe-arch) before smothering the entire shoe
Bare Essentials Shoe Cleaning Kit $12
1. Paper Towel and/or Rag (wiper/scrubber)$1
2. Toothbrush (scrubber) $2
3. Dishwashing liquid (basic shoe sole & mid-sole cleaner) $1
4. Woolite (basic shoe-upper cleaner) $5
5. Shout (stain remover) $3
Upscale Shoe Cleaning Kit $33
1. The Essentials Cleaning Kit (basic supplies) $11
2. Mr. Clean Magic Eraser (tough-stain removal) $2
3. ShoeMGK Cleaner & Conditioner (all-around cleaning) $10
4. Windex (patent leather) $4
*OPTIONAL: Add $10 for a Nubuck/Suede Cleaning Kit if you have shoes made of nubuck/suede or synthetic nubuck/suede
RESULTS AT-A-GLANCE
SHOE-UPPERS: Canvas, Mesh, Vinyl
General Cleaning
1st Choice: Woolite $4
2nd Choice: ShoeMGK Cleaner and Conditioner $10
Last Choice: Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action Gel Cleaner $5
Woolite is my first choice because it’s gentle, effective, easy to acquire and the cheapest of the lot. It also has an established reputation of cleaning delicate fabrics since Mom’s around the world trust their delicates to the stuff. ShoeMGK, although an excellent cleaner, comes in second because of its high price, difficulty to obtain and newness to the cleaning market. The Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action Gel Cleaner rounds out the pack as a more expensive version of laundry detergent.
Stain Removal: WHITES
1st Choice: Clorox Bleach Pen $4
2nd Choice: Shout/Spray N Wash/OxiClean $3
Last Choice: Woolite $4
Clorox Bleach Pen runs circles around every other cleaner when it comes to getting whites white. Generic stain removals are the next best thing and, for day-to-day use, Woolite and some water should do the trick.
Stain Removal: COLORS
1st Choice: Shout/Spray N Wash/OxiClean $3
2nd Choice: Woolite $4
Last Choice: ShoeMGK Cleaner and Conditioner $10
*Wildcard: Mr. Clean Magic Eraser
For colors, products designed for stain removal come in first place, while Woolite (fortified with some elbow grease) comes in second. ShoeMGK Cleaner, although an effective all-around cleaner, comes in the last, again, because of its price and difficulty to obtain. The wildcard here is the miracle worker Mr. Clean Magic Eraser: It’s such an effective cleaner, however, it may just ruin your uppers. Although some regularly clean their entire shoes with the Magic, I save it as a last resort, because there are usually equally effective, less harmful alternatives.
SHOE-UPPERS: Patent Leather
Light Soil: Warm water $0
Heavier Soil: Dishwashing liquid and warm water $2
Heaviest Soil: Windex $4
Real patent leather is leather treated with linseed oil and lacquer, polished to a high gloss finish---a process that was once patented, hence the name. The “patent leather” used in most athletic shoes, however, is leather-coated with plastic or entirely made of plastic. It follows, then, that the care of patent leather sneakers is actually the care of flexible plastic. With time plastic patent leather tends to fade, yellow and crack, and any cleaning agents applied to its surface actually help accelerate the aging process, so if cleaning agents are used, they should be the least corrosive available, used infrequently and preferably when other remedies fail.
SHOE-UPPERS: Nubuck/Suede
1st Choice: Nubuck/Suede Cleaning Kit [suede stone, brush & cleaner] $11
Last Choice: Woolite $4
The Cardinal Rule when cleaning nubuck/suede (a specialized form of leather derived from calfskin) has always been: Never use water to clean nubuck/suede. The reason was that water dries out and stains the leather. Traditionally, nubuck/suede care consisted of a using a brush to restore the nap (i.e. fuzz), a suede stone to remove small stains and, as a last resort, spraying aerosol nubuck/suede cleaner and “dry cleaning” the suede.
Many athletic “nubuck” or “suede” shoes, however, are actually made of a synthetic material called “Chlorenol” (a.k.a. “Durabuck” in Nike’s and “Hydrolite” in Avia’s) that has the look and feel of suede, but is less delicate and more durable than the real deal. Nike recommends cleaning Durabuck with “a soft brush and mild soap and water”. I cleaned different sections of my girl’s light blue adidas Campus IIs (real suede) and my Nike Tokyo URL’s (Chlorenol) with Nubuck/Suede cleaner, Woolite, ShoeMGK Cleaner, Shout, Spray N’ Wash and OxiClean…and water. And while none of the detergent cleaners + water ruined our kicks, their use resulted in a clean, but stiff fabric. Use of the aerosol Nubuck/Suede Cleaner, by contrast, resulted in brighter colors and a softer feel in both the real and synthetic suede kicks, so I ended up cleaning them again with the cleaner just to get them to feel soft and velvety again. The moral of the story, then, is that it pays to use a product designed for its specific purpose even if the material is a man-made version of the real thing.
SHOE-BOTTOMS: Soles/Mid-Soles
Light Soil: Dishwashing liquid and warm water
Heavy Soil: Shout/Spray N Wash/Oxi Clean $3 Simple Green $4/Shoe MGK Cleaner & Condtioner $10
Heaviest Soil: COLORED Sole---Mr. Clean Magic Eraser $2
WHITE Sole---Clorox Bleach Pen $4
If you’re careful about how you treat your kicks when you’re wearing them, you shouldn’t need much more than a toothbrush, a drop of dishwashing liquid and a bit of warm water to clean your soles and mid-soles. Sometimes, you gotta kick it up a notch, in which case most all-purpose cleaners will do the trick, but in a pinch you can depend on Mr. Clean Magic Eraser and Clorox Bleach Pen to do the heavy lifting. Again, adhere to the MORELWORKS Shoe Cleaning philosophy: the least amount of chemicals causes the least amount of damage, so start with the least abrasive solutions and work your way up to the more heavy-duty solutions.
PRODUCT REVIEWS
*Clorox Bleach Pen
*Dishwashing Liquid (Joy, Dawn, Palmolive, etc.)
*Eraser (the pencil kind)
*Gel Cleaner (Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action)
*Household Cleaners All-Purpose (e.g. 409, OxiClean, Simple Green)
*Instant Sneaker Cleaner (Foot Locker/Champs Sports/Foot Action)
*Isopropyl Alcohol
*Mr. Clean Magic Eraser
*Nubuck/Suede Cleaning Kit
*Shoe MGK Cleaner & Conditioner
*Stain Removers: Shout (OxiClean, Spray N Wash, Shout)
*Window Cleaners: Windex, Rite-Aid Glass Cleaner
*Woolite
Clorox Bleach Pen
USE: White soles, white mid-soles, and white uppers made of vinyl and mesh
OVERALL RATING: 9 out of 10
PRICE: $4
AMOUNT: 2 oz.
This gel bleach-in-a-pen works wonders on whites of all types (e.g. uppers, lowers, rubber, canvas, mesh, etc.) and even beats out Mr. Clean’s Magic Eraser when it comes to cleaning the Vans sidewalls. The pen comes with a double-sided applicator: fine point on one side, broad on the other. The gel is great but the applicator isn’t so ignore the scrubber supplied; it doesn’t work well and you’ll find yourself dispensing a bunch of gel instead of scrubbing your shoes. Instead, apply the gel to a separate brush (e.g. a toothbrush) and get your cleaning on. Any bleach product consistently used will, over time, yellow the item cleaned, so I’d save the Clorox Bleach Pen for heavy soiled items and stick to mild alternatives for day-to-day cleaning. That said, the Clorox Bleach Pen is a must-have in any serious sneaker cleaner’s arsenal.
PROS: Highly effective, dispenses easily, readily available
CONS: Brush/applicator tip is ineffective, cost (for amount supplied), may yellow after repeated use